Amazing 1 Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Oh, if you’re anything like me, sometimes you just need a hug in a bowl, right? And honey, there is no dessert that feels cozier or more like home than a perfect bowl of Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding. Forget those instant, plasticky versions you grab at the store! This recipe—the one I finally nailed down after testing a million batches—is the real deal.

We are talking about layers of velvety, rich custard that just melts in your mouth. Every bite is perfectly balanced by sweet, soft bananas, those slightly softened vanilla wafers, and, the grand finale, a towering, fluffy meringue that bakes up to a gorgeous golden brown. This isn’t just pudding; it’s tradition. If you’re looking for that definitive, deeply satisfying Southern flavor that Grandma used to make, you’ve found it. I promise, you’re going to want to bookmark this version right now.

Why This Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding Recipe Stands Out

Why bother with all this effort? Because mediocre pudding just won’t cut it, darling! This recipe delivers that authentic Southern comfort you crave every time. It’s surprisingly quick to assemble, too!

• True Southern Texture: The custard is thick, rich, and never runny.
• Perfect Layers: Proper layering keeps the wafers from vanishing too fast.
• That Meringue Topping: Fluffy, sweet, and perfectly toasted on top.
• Reliable Results: This method has been tested and loved for generations.

Ingredients for the Best Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Okay, listen up, because getting the ingredient lineup right is half the battle won when making true Southern banana pudding. We don’t mess around with substitutes here! Specifically, the bananas need to be ripe—yellow with just a few brown freckles—so they collapse beautifully into the pudding, but not so mushy they turn brown instantly when you slice them.

And please, don’t be tempted to use imitation vanilla! That real vanilla extract is what gives the custard its beautiful depth. If you ever need a quick fix for other recipes, I’ve played around with whipping up heavy cream at home, but for this custard, stick to the recipe!

For the Rich Custard Base

These items are what create that amazing, slow-cooked richness. This is where we start, so get your egg yolks separated—we need those whites later for our fluffy cloud top!

• 6 large eggs, separated (Yolks for custard, whites for meringue)
• 1 cup of the granulated sugar
• 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
• 1/4 teaspoon salt
• 3 cups whole milk

For Assembly and Topping

This is everything else that layers up to pudding heaven—the cookies that get delightfully soggy, the butter that makes the custard glossy, and the ingredients for that glorious meringue.

• 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
• 1/2 cup butter, cut into small cubes
• 5 ripe bananas, sliced about 1/4 inch thick
• 1 box (11 ounces) vanilla wafer cookies (Don’t skimp on these!)
• The remaining 1/2 cup granulated sugar (for the meringue)
• The 6 reserved egg whites

Step-by-Step Instructions for Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Alright, this is where the magic happens, but you need to stay focused! Nothing ruins a batch faster than rushing this cooking stage. We need patience for that perfect mouthfeel. Remember, the oven needs to be humming along at 350 degrees F while you get everything else ready.

Before we dive into the custard, if you’ve ever struggled with a sticky bottom on baked desserts, I highly recommend checking out my tips on making a little homemade custard base for other things—it helps create a non-stick surface that works here too, though we are mostly relying on a good 9×13 dish for this one.

Preparing the Creamy Custard

First things first: grab a medium saucepan. In that pan, whisk together your egg yolks, one cup of the sugar, the flour, and the salt until they are completely uniform. Now, slowly whisk in the milk until it’s totally smooth. You’re going to put this over medium heat. The key here is constant stirring! Don’t walk away! We need the custard to thicken enough that it coats the back of your spoon. You’ll know it’s ready when you run your finger across the back of the spoon and the line stays clearly defined.

Pro Tip Alert: If you let this boil, you’ll end up with scrambled eggs, not custard! Keep that heat medium and just let it simmer gently until thickened. Once it’s thick, pull it right off the heat immediately. Stir in your vanilla extract and those cubes of butter until that butter just melts right into the hot mixture. Let this cool down a touch before we start layering.

Layering Your Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Now for the fun part! Take your 9×13 baking dish—make sure it’s clean—and start building those delicious levels. Begin with a nice, single layer of vanilla wafers right across the bottom. Next, arrange a good layer of your sliced bananas right on top of those cookies. Now, grab about one-third of that slightly cooled custard and pour it gently over the bananas. You want to make sure that custard seeps down into all the nooks and crannies!

Repeat that process—wafers, bananas, custard—two more times. You should end with a final layer of that creamy custard on top. Make sure the banana slices don’t peek out too much because we don’t want them burning on top!

Achieving the Perfect Meringue Topping and Bake

Time to whip those reserved egg whites! Use a super clean bowl—any fat residue will stop them from whipping up right. Beat those whites until they just start forming soft peaks. Then, slow down and gradually start adding that remaining half-cup of sugar, sprinkling it in slowly. Keep beating until those peaks are stiff, glossy, and they hold their shape proudly! When you are pleased, spoon that meringue right over the custard top. You absolutely must seal it to the edges of the baking dish—this stops the meringue from ‘weeping’ later.

Slide that beauty into the 350-degree oven. It only needs 12 to 15 quick minutes. You are looking for light golden-brown spots on that beautiful meringue peak. Set a timer, because it goes fast!

Expert Tips for Perfect Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Even though the steps look straightforward, the little tricks are what take this Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding from good to legendary. I’ve learned a few things over the years that save time and prevent those sad, runny puddings that happen when you aren’t careful!

If you’re making this for a picnic later, you might want to look at my tips for making classic homemade doughnuts, because the principles of preventing sogginess are surprisingly similar!

Banana Selection and Assembly Timing

My main note on bananas, which I scribbled onto my recipe card years ago, is to use them while they are still slightly firm. If they are super soft, you’ll end up with mush instead of slices once everything cools and settles. Also, timing is everything! You want to assemble the layers right before you whip the meringue. If you assemble it too far ahead, those vanilla wafers start to turn to paste before you even get the meringue on.

Here’s my personal trick: I always let the pudding sit on the counter for about an hour after it comes out of the oven before I stick it in the fridge. That initial chill helps the custard set up beautifully before it gets icy cold.

Meringue Management and Alternative Toppings

If the word ‘meringue’ sends you running, don’t worry! You have an excellent emergency option. If you really don’t want to deal with whipping whites, skip steps 6 through 8 and just top the final custard layer with a generous layer of lightly sweetened whipped cream instead. It’s delicious, though it definitely changes the vibe from ‘old fashioned’ to ‘quick and creamy.’

If you do stick with the meringue, remember to seal it to the dish. If you worry about it weeping (where little drops of sugar water form), make sure your egg whites are completely free of any yolk, and that you’re beating the sugar in slowly until you get those stiff peaks. It’s worth the little bit of extra elbow grease!

Variations on Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

While this recipe is perfection just the way it is—that rich custard is truly unbeatable—sometimes a cook just needs to play a little bit, right? That’s the fun of these Southern classics! They are so sturdy that they welcome small changes beautifully.

For instance, if you want a little crunch, I always suggest toasting some chopped pecans. Toss about a half cup of chopped pecans lightly in a dry skillet until they smell nutty, let them cool, and mix them in right when you layer the bananas. It adds such a fantastic texture contrast!

Another fun swap? If you happen to find those Nilla Wafers lacking, you can try substituting them with shortbread cookies, just be aware they will soften up even faster. Or, if you want to lean into the spice cabinet, try adding just a tiny dash of ground nutmeg (like just a pinch!) into the custard mixture while it’s cooking. It pairs surprisingly well with the vanilla. If you’ve ever tried making coconut lemon curd cookies, you know how a small spice can change everything!

Serving and Storing Your Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Remember that very last step? Don’t you dare touch that dish for hours! It has to cool completely before it even thinks about going into the fridge. This cooling time is non-negotiable because it allows that rich custard to fully set up beneath the meringue. Seriously, the pudding needs at least three hours in the refrigerator.

Once it’s chilling, cover your 9×13 dish tightly with plastic wrap—make sure the plastic isn’t touching that beautiful meringue top if you can help it! It stays great in the fridge for about three days. Honestly, it’s best on day one or two, before those vanilla wafers get *too* soft!

Frequently Asked Questions About Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

When you make a truly classic recipe like this, people always have questions, and I totally get it! We want that perfect texture every single time we serve up this southern favorite. Don’t fret if things seem tricky; these little troubleshooting tips usually solve every common pudding problem.

If you’re looking for an even easier dessert, I have a recipe for no-bake Oreo dessert that might be your speed, but trust me, this baked pudding is worth the extra stirring!

Can I make this banana pudding ahead of time?

Yes, but you have to manage your layers! You can absolutely get the custard cooked, the bananas sliced, and the wafers layered up to two days ahead of time. Cover it tightly and keep that in the fridge. However, you must wait until you are ready to bake—like, 30 minutes before you want to pop it in the oven—to whip your egg whites and spread that meringue on top. If you put meringue on too early, it gets sloppy!

Why is my custard too thin?

Nine times out of ten, this means you didn’t cook it long enough, or you didn’t whisk constantly. Remember, you need that mixture to completely coat the back of the spoon. If your heat was too low, it takes forever! Or maybe you didn’t get enough air incorporated when you whisked the flour and yolks first. Once you pull it off the heat, it will continue to thicken slightly as it cools, but if it’s truly soupy, it just needed a few extra minutes simmering on medium heat.

What is the best way to prevent soggy vanilla wafers?

The vanilla wafers are supposed to soften up a little bit—that’s part of the tradition! But if you hate them dissolving completely, here’s my trick: when you do your first layer of custard over the wafers, use just a tiny bit less than you did in the next two layers. Also, make sure those wafers are packed snugly together on the bottom so the custard doesn’t pool too much in one spot. That dense bottom layer helps them hold their structure longer!

Nutritional Snapshot for Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding

Now, I have to be honest with you—this banana pudding is pure, decadent comfort food, folks! Because we are using whole milk, real butter, and all that glorious sugar for the custard and meringue, it definitely lands on the richer side. This isn’t a low-sugar snack, but hey, when you’re eating something this good, who is counting, right?

These numbers come straight from my testing, but please remember that these are just estimates. Where you get your ingredients—like the size of your bananas or the exact brand of wafers—can slightly shift the totals. Treat these figures as a general guide for sharing with your family!

• Serving Size: 1 serving
• Calories: About 350 calories (Worth every single one!)
• Sugar: Roughly 45g
• Fat: Around 15g total fat
• Protein: About 8g
• Carbohydrates: Around 50g

If you’re looking to lighten things up, you could swap the whole milk for 2% or use half the amount of sugar in the meringue, but honestly, I haven’t tried it that way because why mess with a classic?

Share Your Thoughts on This Classic Pudding

Well, we made it! We’ve journeyed from raw eggs to golden meringue, and hopefully, your kitchen smells like pure Southern comfort right now. I truly hope this Old Fashioned Southern Banana Pudding brings as much warmth and happiness to your table as it does to mine.

Now, I need to know what you think! Did this nail that nostalgic, creamy texture you were looking for? Please take a second to rate this recipe right down below—five stars if you think it’s the best pudding you’ve ever made! And leave me a comment telling me about your absolute favorite Southern dessert memory. Was it Granny’s pecan pie or maybe a special shortcake?

If you loved this recipe, don’t keep it a secret! Snap a picture and share it on social media so your friends can see how gorgeous your meringue turned out. And hey, if you’re already planning the next showstopper dessert, maybe check out my incredibly easy recipe for easy cheesecake—it’s a totally different vibe but just as satisfying!

Happy baking, y’all, and thanks for letting me share a piece of my family’s kitchen with yours!

Print