Amazing 16 Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

I’m telling you, if you want to win any potluck or watch party, forget the sad little veggie trays! We need appetizers that bring the flavor drama, and what’s more dramatic than a perfect sweet, spicy, and savory combination? I’ve mastered the grill over the years, and my absolute go-to for wowing people is the Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Popper. Seriously, it’s the trifecta!

You get that beautiful heat from the jalapeno, which is instantly soothed by the cool, creamy cheese filling, but then—BAM—the grilled, caramelized sweetness of the pineapple kicks in. And holding it all together? Crispy, smoky bacon. This recipe is easy to assemble, but the outdoor grilling truly takes it over the top. Trust me, these poppers disappear faster than popcorn at the end of a movie.

Why You Will Love These Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

Oh my gosh, why will you love them? Let’s just count the ways! If you ever need an appetizer that screams ‘special occasion’ without needing to slave away all day, this is it. Honestly, I love watching people’s faces when they take that first bite. It’s such a shock of good flavor!

• The Ultimate Flavor Balance: It hits sweet, spicy, and savory notes all in one bite. That grilled pineapple just changes everything!
• Perfect for the Grill: Cooking them outside means less cleanup inside and that wonderful smoky essence that only grilling can provide.
• Surprisingly Quick Assembly: Even stuffing and wrapping 16 pieces goes fast once you get into a rhythm. You can whip these up in under 20 minutes of prep time.
• Serious Crowd Pleaser: Honestly, I have never had a single person turn one down. They look fancy but taste like pure fun.
• Customizeable Heat: You control the burn! Want mild? Scrape out every last bit of white pith. Want fire? Leave a little in!

Really, the combination of the creamy filling against that crisp bacon is what makes this appetizer shine. Get ready for requests for this recipe!

Ingredients for Perfect Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

Okay, here’s where we talk precision. For an appetizer this delicate—balancing heat, fat, and sweetness—you absolutely cannot eyeball the ingredients. I learned the hard way that using standard jalapenos when the recipe calls for big ones means you end up with filling spilling everywhere! You need substance to hold up to the grill for this recipe.

Make sure you have everything ready to go before you start splitting the peppers. Having your cream cheese truly softened saves your arm! Here’s the list. Treat it like gold; these specific quantities make the magic happen:

• 8 large jalapenos: Yes, they need to be large enough to cradle a generous amount of filling.
• 8 oz cream cheese, softened: Make sure this is soft enough to mix easily without lumps, but not melted!
• 1/4 cup shredded cheddar cheese: I like sharp cheddar here for a little extra bite.
• 1/4 cup finely diced fresh pineapple: Do not use canned, please! Fresh pineapple caramelizes so much better on the grill.
• 1 teaspoon lime juice: This wakes up the cheese mixture beautifully.
• 1/2 teaspoon cumin: A little earthy depth goes a long way here.
• 1/4 teaspoon salt: Just a touch to bring out the flavors.
• 16 thin slices bacon: This is crucial! Thin bacon cooks faster and gets crispier before the jalapeno overcooks. You need exactly two slices per stuffed pepper half.

Seriously, gathering these precise ingredients is half the battle won. Once you have these ready, the assembly is a piece of cake—or, well, a piece of popper!

Essential Equipment for Making Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

You know I love keeping things simple, but even a simple appetizer deserves the right tools! You don’t need a whole kitchen overhaul for these, but having the right gear handy makes the stuffing and grilling process so much smoother. We are going for efficiency here, people!

First things first, you absolutely need a good, sharp **knife and a sturdy cutting board**. Since we are slicing jalapenos lengthwise and removing those seeds, a stable surface prevents any disastrous slips. A sharp knife makes slicing those peppers clean, which leaves you more pepper casing to hold the filling.

Next, for mixing up that amazing creamy interior, grab yourself a solid **medium mixing bowl**. You’ll also want a **rubber spatula or a wooden spoon**. I prefer a spatula because it helps scrape every last bit of that cheesy pineapple deliciousness out when you’re spooning it into the peppers.

Now for the star of the show: the grill! You need a **working grill preheated to medium heat**. A solid set of **long-handled tongs** is non-negotiable here. Those poppers are hot, and bacon fat drips, so you definitely don’t want to be hovering too close while flipping them.

Finally, grab a **small spoon or melon baller** for scooping the filling into the pepper halves. Precision helps keep the filling contained so it doesn’t ooze out before the bacon has a chance to seal it up tight on the grate. Get these tools ready, and you are halfway to appetizer heaven!

Step-by-Step Instructions to Grill Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

Okay, this is where the fun really starts! We go from prep bowl to the open flame, and that combination of flavors starts to marry together perfectly. Don’t rush the grill timing—that’s the secret to bacon that’s crisp but not burned. If you’re looking for an indoor option sometime, check out how to make awesome air fryer jalapeno poppers, but for now, we’re grilling!

Preparing the Jalapenos and Filling

First, you need to get those jalapenos ready for their cheesy delivery! Get a sharp knife and carefully slice every one of the 8 large peppers right down the middle lengthwise. You need to completely scoop out all the seeds and, this is important for managing the heat, scrape out as much of that white membrane (the pith) as you can! If you leave too much of the membrane, these will pack a serious punch. Rinse the insides quickly with water and pat them totally dry.

Now for the filling! In your mixing bowl, mash together that softened cream cheese, cheddar, diced fresh pineapple, lime juice, cumin, and salt. Make sure that pineapple is mixed evenly throughout the cheese; you don’t want one popper to have a dry corner and another one overflowing with fruit. Use a little spoon to carefully fill each hollowed-out pepper half with the mixture. Don’t overstuff them, or the cheese will burst out when it melts!

Wrapping and Grilling the Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

Time to wrap these beauties up! Take one slice of thin bacon and wrap it tightly around the stuffed pepper half. You want the ends of the bacon to overlap slightly under the popper so it stays flat on the grill. If you find the bacon keeps sliding, don’t hesitate to tap a toothpick through the overlapping ends—it makes flipping so much easier later on!

Next, preheat your grill to medium heat. Medium heat is what we need so the bacon has time to render and get crispy before the pepper itself burns on the outside. Place the poppers directly onto the grates, and here is the critical first step: place them bacon-side down first. Cook them like that for about 4 to 5 minutes until you see the bacon starting to brown nicely. Then, gently turn them over. Keep turning every few minutes until the bacon is totally crisp, which usually takes another 5 to 7 minutes. You want the jalapenos feeling tender when you gently press them. When they look perfect—golden, crisp, and slightly charred—pull them off immediately and let them chill out for a few minutes before serving!

Tips for Making the Best Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

I’ve made these poppers more times than I can count for parties, and I’ve definitely learned a few little tricks along the way that take them from good to absolutely legendary. Trust me, these aren’t in the main recipe steps, but they are vital for that gourmet finish!

First up, let’s talk **uniformity**. You need your jalapenos to be roughly the same size, especially the ones you’re stuffing. If you have one tiny pepper and one huge one, the small one will burn to a crisp before the large one is nice and tender. Try to pick peppers that look similar in length and width when you’re at the store—it really helps them cook evenly on those grates.

My biggest tip, and this is crucial for grilling, is watching the **heat control**. Medium heat sounds easy, right? But I always keep a spray bottle of water handy, just in case. If you see the bacon starting to blacken too fast—before it’s even halfway crispy—that means your flame is too high, or you have a flare-up happening because of dripping fat. Gently mist the flames (never spray directly onto the hot coals, only the flames) to bring the heat down immediately. We want rendering and crisping, not charring!

If you want that super intense pineapple kick, here’s a secret: let your finely diced pineapple sit in the lime juice and cumin for about 15 minutes *before* you mix it into the cream cheese. It gives the fruit time to absorb those earthy spices, which really cuts through the richness of the bacon and cheese. It’s a small step, but the flavor payoff is huge.

One final piece of advice: Don’t skip the cooling time! I know they smell amazing coming off the grill, but that melted cheese is lava. Letting them rest for five minutes ensures that the cheese settles back into the pepper cavity just a bit. They are much safer and tastier to eat when they’ve had a moment to breathe outside the heat!

Variations on Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

While I stand by the original recipe—it’s a classic for a reason!—I totally understand that sometimes you need to tweak things depending on what you have kicking around the fridge or what your crowd is into. I love experimenting, and these poppers are super forgiving in the best way possible. It’s so easy to swap out one or two components and create a whole new flavor profile!

If you’re hosting people who love a little extra kick, the easiest switch you can make is ditching the cheddar and substituting it with Pepper Jack cheese. The pepper jack melts beautifully, and the light heat from the Monterey Jack base just complements the jalapeno better than standard cheddar does. It gives it this wonderful, creamy, slightly spicy melt.

For those who really lean into the sweet side of things, you have to try a post-grill drizzle. Right after they come off the heat, hit them with a tiny zig-zag of good quality balsamic glaze. That thick, tangy sweetness pairs unbelievably well with the smoky bacon and the grilled pineapple. It’s gourmet, honestly, and takes zero extra effort!

Another fun one is playing with the bacon itself. If you can find smoked bacon, use it! The extra smokiness elevates the whole grilling experience. If you can’t find smoked, use thick-cut bacon and let it cook just a minute or two longer on the grill to let that flavor really develop. If you’re feeling truly ambitious and have time to make another batch of something spicy, you could even top them with a little bit of homemade jalapeno bacon jam before serving. But honestly, even just those simple cheese or glaze swaps turn these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers into a new favorite!

Serving Suggestions for Your Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

So, you’ve pulled those beautiful, crispy, sweet-and-spicy poppers off the grill. Fantastic! Now you have to decide what to serve them with. Because these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers are so packed with flavor—creamy, smoky, spicy, and sweet—they really sing when paired with something that offers a cooling contrast. I think dipping sauces are mandatory for grilled appetizers; it just makes everything more fun!

My absolute top recommendation is something cool and tangy to cut through the richness of the bacon and cheese. A simple chilled sour cream mixed with a little fresh lime zest and maybe a dash of onion powder works miracles. It brings the temperature down a notch, which is lovely if you went a little heavy on the pepper membrane removal!

If you want something that packs a little more flavor without competing, you have to try my friend’s spicy comeback sauce. It’s got a great kick, but it’s still creamy enough to balance the char from the grill. You can find the recipe for that amazing Spicy Southern Comeback sauce, and it is heavenly with this appetizer—you dip once, and you’re hooked.

Now, if you’re serving these as part of a larger spread and not just as a standalone snack, I always try to balance the heaviness of the bacon with something fresh on the side. A really crisp, lightly dressed green salad or maybe even a vibrant cucumber and dill slaw is perfect. The crunch of the slaw against the soft, warm filling is divine!

Honestly, though, sometimes they are so good on their own you don’t need anything extra at all. But if you do reach for a dip, make sure it’s something refreshing. These poppers are the star of the plate!

Storage and Reheating Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

The worst thing about making something this delicious is seeing leftovers the next day, right? Because they are so cheesy and wrapped in bacon, these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers don’t stay restaurant-crispy forever, but we can definitely keep them tasting great for a few days! Storing them properly is key to getting that satisfying snap back when you reheat them.

Once they have cooled down completely from the grill—and I mean totally cool, because moisture equals sogginess—you need an airtight container. Store them in the fridge, and they should be perfectly fine for about three to four days. Don’t try to stack them too high! If you can place them in a single layer, that’s even better for maintaining their shape, though I usually end up stacking mine somewhat carefully.

Now, for reheating—skip the microwave entirely! Seriously, the microwave turns that beautiful crispy bacon into a rubbery, sad mess. We want to revive that grill char, and that means dry, even heat. I find two methods work best to bring these back to life.

The oven is my go-to for reheating a larger batch. Preheat your oven to about 350°F (175°C). Lay the poppers out on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper—this prevents the cheese from melting directly onto the pan. Pop them in there for about 8 to 10 minutes. Keep an eye on them, but you’ll notice the bacon starts to firm up and crisp again almost instantly. It’s fantastic!

If you are only reheating one or two, the air fryer is your hero! Set it to about 350°F (175°C) for just 4 minutes. This blasts the outside with heat and restores the crunch super quick. They’ll be piping hot and almost as good as fresh off the grill. Enjoy those leftovers!

Frequently Asked Questions About Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

I always get so many questions when people try these for the first time! It makes sense; you’re dealing with fruit, spice, cheese, and bacon all sitting over an open flame. It’s a delicate dance! I tried to cover everything in the main steps, but here are the things I get asked about most often when it comes to taming the heat or changing the cooking method.

How can I adjust the spice level of these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers?

This is probably the number one question! Jalapenos vary so much, right? If you want them super mild—almost like a sweet pepper with a tiny hint of warmth—you’ve got to be aggressive about removing the white membrane, also called the pith. That’s where 90% of the heat lives. Scrape it out with a spoon until the inside looks totally pale. If you want them fiery, leave a good bit of that membrane attached!

If you want to take them from mild to medium-hot without relying purely on the pepper itself, try this: add about 1/8th of a teaspoon of cayenne pepper right into your cream cheese mixture. It gives you a nice, warm background heat that complements the pineapple without being harsh. Don’t go crazy, though; a little cayenne goes a long way when paired with that fatty bacon!

Can I bake these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers instead of grilling?

Yes, absolutely! Grilling gives that lovely char, but sometimes the weather isn’t cooperating, or maybe you just don’t have your grill fired up. Baking works perfectly well, as long as you focus on getting that bacon crisp. I recommend setting your oven to 400°F (200°C). Lay them out on a wire rack set over a baking sheet—the rack is important because it lets the bottom cook evenly and prevents the bacon from sitting in its own grease.

Bake them for about 15 to 20 minutes. You’ll need to check them around the 12-minute mark to see how the bacon is doing. If it’s crisping up nicely, you are good to go! If the bacon is still floppy but the cheese is melting, you might quickly switch your oven to the broiler for the last minute or two, but *watch them like a hawk*! The broiler is fast, and you don’t want to burn that sweet pineapple topping. If you’re looking for another fast oven hack, I have some great tips over on my air fryer jalapeno poppers recipe that would translate well here too, just use low air flow!

Estimated Nutritional Data for Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers

I always get asked about the nutrition when people look at this recipe because bacon and cheese are involved, I get it! But honestly, since these are appetizers that we usually only have a few of, the serving size keeps things quite reasonable. Remember, this data is just an estimate based on using the exact ingredient quantities listed earlier, so your numbers might vary slightly depending on the exact cut of bacon you grab or how much cheese you manage to stuff in there!

I always try to remind folks that the richness here comes mostly from the delicious fat that keeps the bacon perfectly crisp on the grill, but the portion control keeps the joy factor high!

Here’s the breakdown per popper (assuming 16 servings):

• Calories: 120
• Total Fat: 10g (with 5g of that being Saturated Fat, which is pretty standard for bacon and cream cheese)
• Protein: 5g
• Carbohydrates: 3g (thanks largely to that little bit of pineapple!)
• Sugar: 2g
• Sodium: 250mg
• Fiber: 0g
• Cholesterol: 25mg

So there you have it! They are indulgent, sure, but because you only eat a couple at a time, they fit into almost any balanced menu plan. Enjoy them guilt-free!

Share Your Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers Experience

Alright, now that you’ve conquered the grill and created your own batch of tangy, smoky, and sweet perfection, I absolutely want to hear all about it! Cooking is all about sharing, isn’t it? Whether you nailed the crisp bacon on the first try or you had a little flare-up adventure (we’ve all been there!), your feedback helps me and everyone else who tries this recipe.

Did you stick exactly to the recipe, or did you try one of those fun variations we talked about, like adding the balsamic glaze? Perhaps you found a dipping sauce that was even better than my suggestions?

Please, jump down into the comments below and tell me what happened! I really want to know how everyone rates these. Give the recipe a quick star rating—1 star if it brought you shame, 5 stars if your guests begged you for the recipe! Your experience with these Bacon Wrapped Grilled Pineapple Jalapeno Poppers is what keeps this whole cooking community going.

I can’t wait to read your stories and see how you enjoyed your perfectly balanced appetizer!

Print